- In Ontario, the Business Corporations Act (OBCA) or the Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA) governs how companies combine. However, businesses use the term ‘merger’; it does not constitute a separate Ontario law.
- An amalgamation can be short (between a parent and its subsidiary or sister companies) or long (when the companies don’t meet the statutory requirements for a short form). A long-form amalgamation requires the companies to execute an amalgamation agreement and have shareholders approve it.
- The amalgamation certificate will state the effective date. On that date,, the original companies will amalgamate into a single amalgamated corporation that, by operation of law, will succeed to all the assets and assume all the liabilities and obligations of each constituent company as if the amalgamated corporation were the same as each constituent company.
- Companies can also alter their structure by acquiring assets, purchasing shares, entering into plans of arrangement, or carrying out wind-ups. Those are different from mergers.
- You must do due diligence before choosing a structure, as the best structure depends on what you’re buying and the liabilities you’re prepared to take on.
A business combination is a major strategic decision. It can be done for a number of reasons (market expansion, scale, combining complementary businesses, etc.). The structure you pick matters, though; it’s not just about the tax and legal implications. It’s important for corporate governance, the culture of the business, and ultimately for control. Ontario’s principal statutory combination process is known as ‘amalgamation’ (though in practice the terms are used interchangeably). They are not the same. This guide explains the differences, your other options, and when each is appropriate for a Canadian business.
Why Do Businesses Combine In The First Place?
It helps to set your objective before selecting a structure, as most business combinations in Ontario happen for one of these reasons.
Growth is a perfectly legitimate objective (you can grow your customer base, you can grow your market share). However, if you’re combining with a direct competitor, the deal could be subject to review under the Competition Act. So be very careful about presenting reduced competition as your objective.
Other legitimate reasons for a merger might be entering new markets or adding new products, where a complementary business lets you avoid starting over. You can achieve significant efficiencies and cost savings by combining back-office functions, suppliers, or facilities to reduce overhead. Talent and technology can be the real assets in some cases (i.e., a team, a patent, a platform). On succession and exit, a founder approaching retirement may want to join a larger group to achieve liquidity.
The benefits of a combination aren’t automatic and can be counteracted by integration, competitive pressures, and regulatory risk. The deal you’re after will determine the structure you end up with; a deal that is primarily a cost-saving exercise will look very different from one that is really about acquiring a brand or a license.
What Is Meant By The Term “ Merger”?
In everyday business talk, we often say one company “absorbs” another, leaving just one survivor. However, legally speaking in Ontario, there isn’t a distinct “merger” law. What people call a merger is usually just a specific structure, like a share purchase followed by a vertical amalgamation, a court-approved arrangement, or another transaction. What shareholders receive, cash or shares, depends entirely on the deal agreement.
A classic example is a vertical short-form amalgamation, but that works only if the parent company already owns 100% of the subsidiary.
Another myth is that the amalgamated corporation automatically takes on everything. In a share acquisition, the target’s assets and liabilities remain with the target. An asset purchase will require specific transfers. Only in the case of a true amalgamation do you achieve statutory continuity. Keeping the old brand alive is a business decision, not a rule of the deal structure.
What is Amalgamation?
Amalgamation is the statutory process by which two or more corporations amalgamate into one. In Ontario, it is governed by s 174 to s 179 of the OBCA and at the federal level by s 181 to s 186 of the CBCA. People often assume this creates a completely new company, but under Canadian law, it’s a different proposition. As the Supreme Court observed in R. v. Black & Decker, it’s like a river formed by the confluence of two streams. The original companies are not extinguished; they simply exist as one combined corporation. They are not separately liable. The amalgamated corporation assumes all the original companies’ past liabilities. But not everything passed automatically. For instance, statutes generally support the continuation of litigation and require no formal assignment, but you do need to check material contracts for clauses requiring notice, consent, or a default. Licenses, in particular, may require notice, an amendment, or a completely new application.
Short Form vs. Long Form:
Short form amalgamations come in two forms. The first is the vertical short form, where the holding company merges with its wholly owned subsidiaries. The subsidiaries’ shares are canceled, and the parent’s articles are carried forward. You’ll need to check the exact share cancellation and securities provisions under your governing statute in that case. The second is the horizontal short form, where two or more of the parent’s wholly owned subsidiaries merge. Again, you’ll need to check the exact share cancellation and articles provisions under the statute.
For the short forms, director approval is generally sufficient (no shareholder vote or amalgamation agreement required) provided you still satisfy all the required board resolutions and statutory requirements.
Long-form amalgamations are the mechanism for more complicated situations, such as amalgamations of unrelated companies or those with minority shareholders. They require a formal agreement and a special resolution (usually two-thirds). There may be additional approvals required under the articles or class rights (e.g.,a separate class or series vote). Dissenting shareholders have fair value rights, but they must comply with the requisite statutory notice and procedures.
Once the articles are filed, the Director’s certificate establishes the legal effective date, and the companies become a single amalgamated corporation. Former shareholders do not automatically get shares (the agreement can provide for cash or other consideration where permitted by law).
Why Is Due Diligence Essential For A Merger And Amalgamation?
Due diligence is essential in any business combination because it tells you precisely what you’re buying and what liabilities you’re taking on. For an Ontario transaction, your due diligence checklist should include corporate records (minute books, articles of incorporation, by-laws, securities register, etc.), financial and tax records (statements, returns, assessments, etc.), and, of course, the contracts. Review the contracts carefully, particularly any change-of-control or anti-assignment clauses. A share purchase may trigger a change of control but not an assignment; an asset purchase will normally require an assignment; amalgamation clauses need to be looked at separately. You will also need to review the IP and employment agreements. If the target has any hidden debts, an asset purchase may be the safer route. If the value of the business is in the contracts, you may be inclined to go for an amalgamation, but you need to confirm the target has an amalgamation clause in place, as continuity is not necessarily assured.
Amalgamation vs. Share Purchase vs. Asset Purchase:
Ontario business owners generally have three ways in which to do a deal. Each structure has very different corporate, tax, and contractual implications.
If you choose amalgamation, the original companies merge into a single amalgamated corporation. By operation of law, this entity continues as and is deemed to be the same as each constituent company. It automatically succeeds to all assets, rights, liabilities, and obligations. This means all predecessor liabilities continue in the amalgamated corporation.
With a share purchase, you’re not actually “stepping into the owner’s shoes”. You become a shareholder, and the company continues to exist with its assets, contracts, and liabilities.
If you’re buying assets, you pick and choose the assets you want to buy (e.g., specific equipment, specific trademarks, specific agreements, etc.). Only the assets you select, and any liabilities you contractually assume, pass to you; the seller retains the debts. You may still be exposed to employment, environmental, and tax statutory successor liabilities. You will often also need third-party consent to properly assign certain contracts and/or licenses.
What’s The Difference Between A Merger And An Amalgamation?
Here is how the actual structures really differ:
Legal process: A merger is a general business term, whereas an amalgamation is a formal statutory process under Ontario or federal law.
Who survives? In a share or asset acquisition, one company absorbs the other. In an amalgamation, the predecessor companies continue as one amalgamated entity.
When it’s official: acquisitions close on the date in the agreement; an amalgamation takes effect on the date the government issues the certificate.
Approvals: Acquisitions will of course require the relevant board, shareholder, class, court or regulatory approvals depending on the nature of the transaction. Amalgamations have a very clear set of statutory steps which may require nothing more than board approval or a shareholder vote.
Shareholders: In a share acquisition, arrangement, or long-form amalgamation, shareholders may receive cash or securities, and dissenters will have certain rights.
Who’s in charge? It depends on the transaction documents, not the label. An amalgamation could involve a reconstituted board that includes the previous directors.
Assets and debts: Acquisitions are based on the contract and transfer assets and liabilities accordingly. Amalgamation provides statutory continuity, reducing the number of individual conveyances you need to do, but you still need to deal with lenders, tax, licenses, and contracts.
Complexity: Short-form amalgamations are pretty straightforward; long-form ones, and some acquisitions, can get quite complex depending on the setup.
Branding is a business integration issue, not a legal distinction. You can keep brands, mix brands, or change brands in any structure.
So share or asset acquisitions work for takeovers. Amalgamations work for arm’s-length combinations, internal reorgs as part of a streamlining exercise.
The short answer is that a merger is just a general term. If you’re looking at a statutory combination where the predecessor companies continue as one, then you’re looking at an amalgamation.
What Other Ways Are There Of Combining Businesses?
Amalgamation is not the only way to combine businesses. There are plenty of other options depending on your goals:
For more complex transactions involving different classes of shareholders or creditors, you could use a court-supervised plan of arrangement. That would require board and shareholder approval, fairness considerations, and potentially compliance with securities laws. It’s a flexible route, but it can be more expensive and complex than a straight amalgamation.
If you’re looking to absorb a subsidiary, then a statutory wind-up is an alternative. It’s a complex process, and you’ll need a corporate and tax review. Tax deferral may be available through a Section 88 wind-up rollover (i.e., tax-deferred treatment) if the conditions are met, but this would require advice from a tax adviser.
There’s also the butterfly transaction. It’s a specialist, tax-oriented technique in which the company’s assets are split between the shareholders (for instance, in a family split). You can get tax-deferred treatment if you meet the appropriate statutory conditions.
Share rollovers and holding company reorganizations are fairly common. Sections 51, 85, and 86 will likely be relevant from a tax perspective, so don’t assume no tax is triggered. A reorganization of this nature will require consideration of creditor, tax, securities, and corporate issues.
In the case of a public company, a takeover bid is an offer to buy the company’s shares from all shareholders. That can lead to a control acquisition, followed by a second-step transaction. That scenario requires specialist advice on securities, exchanges, and public M&A.
To work closely while remaining separate, a joint venture or partnership is the way to go. You’d need to decide which type of joint venture (contractual, corporate, partnership) best fits your project.
Bottom line: no single answer will work for everyone. It will depend on your objectives, your company structure, and the level of complexity you’re prepared to embrace.
Key Regulatory and Strategic Factors to Consider:
Before you get too deep into the deal structure, look beyond the documents. Several regulatory and strategic issues can affect how the transaction plays out, whether it’s a share purchase, an asset purchase, or an amalgamation.
- Competition Act: If you’re combining with a competitor, then the deal will likely be subject to a merger review. This will involve checking the notification thresholds. Even if the deal is not notifiable, the Competition Bureau may still review it if it’s likely to have an adverse effect on competition.
- Investment Canada Act: If it’s a non-Canadian buying the business, you’ll have to consider foreign investment notification, review, and national security assessments.
- Lender consent: You’ll need to look at the loan covenants, the security registrations and the existing guarantees. You’ll almost certainly need lender consent to go ahead.
- Regulatory Licenses: Certain sectors have specific regulatory approvals. You’ll need to review license continuity to confirm the business can operate legally post-deal.
- Environmental liabilities: Be mindful that the amalgamated or acquired business may have historical environmental exposure (for past operations).
- Employees: Employment continuity varies considerably by structure. In a share purchase or amalgamation, the employees will generally remain with the corporation. In an asset purchase, employment continuity depends on whether the buyer will offer the jobs and on provincial employment laws.
Strategic Considerations: How To Decide Between A Merger, An Amalgamation, And Other Options?
For speed and control, a share purchase gives you full control immediately after closing. A vertical short-form amalgamation is generally a subsequent step, since you must first own the target company completely.
A realistic example (the tech acquisition): A big tech company wanting to acquire a smaller software startup will buy all the startup’s shares to take control quickly. The startup will retain its assets and its existing liabilities. The buyer will, of course, want to fully integrate the startup into its own structure, so it will complete a vertical short-form amalgamation upon closing. Because the buyer now owns 100% of the startup, the short-form amalgamation is all that is required (no shareholder vote is needed), and it will simply amalgamate the two companies into one. This lets the buyer achieve the integration it wants without the onerous paperwork of a long-form amalgamation.
For similarly sized businesses, amalgamation doesn’t necessarily lead to equal governance. You’ve still got to work out the ownership, the exchange ratios and the board rights.
For tax efficiency, qualifying amalgamations can qualify for conditional section 87 rollover treatment (which of course requires a specialist tax review). Section 88 is largely of relevance to wind-ups.
For simplicity, a parent and its wholly owned subsidiary can proceed with a short-form amalgamation. Where the conditions are met, it will skip the need to have an amalgamation agreement or shareholder approval (though, of course, lender, tax, license, and regulatory issues may still arise).
To help manage liability, an asset purchase may allow selective assumption. A share purchase does not in any way avoid the target’s liabilities, and statutory successor liabilities may still arise.
For contract protection, amalgamation may be of assistance in relation to assignment issues (subject to the amalgamation and reorganization provisions of the agreement).
How Can A Lawyer Assist With An Amalgamation?
A lawyer will help you choose the right structure, handle the documentation, and complete the paperwork. We’ll explain the various structures and legal requirements clearly. We’ll also work with appropriate tax advisers on the tax implications and help identify solvency issues, lender consent, and creditor rights.
Clients choose Pacific Legal because:
- We aim to act as external general counsel to private businesses in Ontario. That means we provide advice on share purchases, asset purchases, amalgamations, arrangements and/or reorganizations and on contracts and governance. We are very clear about our scope of work, and we don’t imply that we will be your ongoing retainer.
- Our M&A practice covers the full spectrum of the transaction, from structuring through due diligence, filings, and the actual closing.
Ready to look at your options? A seasoned advisor can help you work through the various options of a share purchase, asset purchase, amalgamation, arrangement, or reorganization. Contact Pacific Legal today!








