Ontario construction projects are associated with extensive investments, multilateral interactions between various parties, and legal considerations. The Construction Lien Act offers a potent legal mechanism that contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers may use in order to obtain payment for their efforts in the event of payment disputes. Nevertheless, landlords as well as other interested parties also possess valid defences in cases where they are confronted with unreasonable or incorrectly filed cases.
It is important to understand the defence against a construction lien in Ontario in order to secure your property and funds. The Construction Act, S.O. 2017, c. 24 (previously referred to as the Builders Lien Act) creates a set of strict deadlines, procedural conditions, and other substantial grounds which can underlie the successful defences. Be it an owner of a property who has already paid work, a general contractor with subcontractors seeking claims or anyone who finds him/herself in a payment dispute, understanding what your rights are and what your defences are can make a difference between losing your property to a claim of lien and defending your legitimate interests.
This guide covers the practical tactics of fending off claims of construction liens under the Ontario Construction Act, reviews recent lawsuits, and offers practical advice to any person who finds himself or herself in a construction lien dispute within Ontario.
Also Read: A Business Owner’s Guide to Arbitration vs. Litigation in Ontario
What are Construction Liens in Ontario?
A construction lien is a legal claim registered against a property to secure payment for labour, materials, or services provided during construction, renovation, or improvement work. The Construction Lien Act provides such rights to the contractors, subcontractors, suppliers of materials, and other parties who contribute to the betterment of a property in a way that they are able to tie up the property until they are paid to do their work.
Think of a construction lien as a legal hold on your property. Consider a scenario in which you pay a contractor to makeover your kitchen for 50,000 dollars. The plumber is contracted by the contractor at a rate of $15,000. When you pay the contractor who does not pay the plumber, the plumber is able to bring a construction lien in Ontario on your property despite having been paid in full by the contractor. This lien prevents you from selling or refinancing your property until the dispute is resolved.
Under Section 14(1) of the Construction Act, liens must be registered against the property’s title at the local land registry office. Once registered, the lien creates a legal cloud on the title, which can prevent property sales, mortgage refinancing, and other transactions. The lien also gives the claimant the right to potentially force a sale of the property through court proceedings if payment isn’t resolved.
The Ontario Construction Act recognizes several types of lien claimants, including general contractors, subcontractors, material suppliers, equipment renters, architects, engineers, and even workers who provide labour on the project. Section 1 of the Act defines “services or materials” broadly to encompass virtually any contribution to improving a property. Each claimant has specific rights and obligations under the Act, but all share the common goal of securing payment through the property itself.
Also Read: The Ontario Arbitration Handbook: A Business and Legal Guide to Resolving Disputes
Defences Against Construction Lien Claims
When served with a construction lien claim, you’re not without options. The Construction Act provides several substantive and procedural defences that can defeat or reduce lien claims. Understanding these defences is the first step toward protecting your interests.
Payment Already Made is one of the most straightforward defences. If you’ve already paid for the work, materials, or services claimed in the lien, you have a complete defence against that claim. But it is more complicated in the case of contractor-subcontractor conflicts. Here is a scenario: You pay a general contractor $100,000, and they end up receiving the sum. The plumber is not paid his/her $30,000 by the contractor. The plumber files a lien against your property. Although you have paid the contractor, you can still be held liable to the subcontractor to the extent of the amount that you paid the contractor. This is where proper holdback provisions become critical.
The holdback defence is built into the Construction Lien Act framework. Section 22 of the Act requires property owners to retain 10% of the price of the services or materials as they are supplied as a “holdback” for a specified period after substantial completion. This holdback protects owners who properly maintain it from personal liability for claims by subcontractors and suppliers, even if the general contractor fails to pay them.
Defects and deficiencies in work provide another defence category. When the work asserted in the lien is materially defective, incomplete or otherwise not meeting the requirements of the contract, then you might be able to defend against the entire amount of the lien. It is not merely the defence that the work is not perfect; it must prove that the work is deficient so that non-payment or less than full payment must be paid. You might counterclaim for the cost of remedying defects, which can offset or eliminate the lien claim.
Procedural defects represent a powerful category of defences under the Ontario Construction Act. The Act has very strict requirements to register and maintain liens, and any failure to do so can make a lien invalid. Some of the common procedural defences are:
- Late registration: According to Section 31(2), liens should generally be registered within 60 days of the last supply of services or materials. Failure to meet this deadline renders the lien void.
- Improper lien description: Section 34 requires liens to accurately describe the property, the services or materials provided, and the amount claimed.
- Failure to preserve the lien: Section 36 requires lienholders to preserve their claims within 45 days by commencing an action and registering a certificate of action.
- Lack of privity: In some circumstances, parties too remote from the project may lack standing to claim a lien.
The case of Urbancorp Cumberland 2 GP Inc. (Re), 2020 ONCA 197, examined trust provisions and procedural compliance under the Construction Act, providing important guidance on how construction trusts operate in insolvency proceedings. This decision from the Ontario Court of Appeal clarified that statutory trusts under Section 9 of the Act can be effective even in insolvency situations, demonstrating the strong protections afforded to contractors and subcontractors.
Set-offs and counterclaims allow you to reduce lien amounts by asserting your own claims against the lien claimant. Example: A contractor who claims damages of $50,000 and yet their work caused you to pay damages of $20,000, you could counterclaim the $20,000, and the amount of the valid lien would then reduce to to$30,0000.
Expiry and abandonment defences apply when lien claimants fail to prosecute their claims within the required timeframes. Section 37 of the Construction Act requires lienholders to set the action down for trial within 90 days after the last date for preservation. If a lien claimant registers a lien but never follows through with legal action within the prescribed period, the lien expires and can be removed from the title.
Also Read: Resolving Corporate Disputes with A Toronto Commercial Litigation Lawyer
What to Do When Served with a Construction Lien
The process of getting a construction lien notice in Ontario of a construction lien against your property may be considered terrifying, yet taking immediate, strategic steps is critical. The following is a real-life roadmap when responding.
- Don’t panic, but don’t delay. Construction lien proceedings move quickly, with tight statutory deadlines. The moment you discover a lien has been registered against your property or receive notice of a lien claim, time becomes your most valuable resource. Document the date you received notice and immediately consult with legal counsel experienced in construction lien matters.
- Gather all documentation related to the project. Collect your contract, payment records, invoices, change orders, correspondence with contractors, proof of payments, inspection reports, and any documentation of deficiencies or disputes. Comprehensive documentation often makes the difference between successfully defending a claim and facing liability.
- Review the lien carefully for procedural defects. Check whether the lien was registered within the 60-day window under Section 31, whether it accurately describes your property, whether the claimed amount is properly calculated, and whether the claimant has proper standing to file a lien. Even small errors in lien registration can provide grounds for having the lien declared invalid.
- Assess your holdback position. Determine whether you’ve properly maintained the required 10% holdback under Section 22 of the Construction Lien Act of Ontario. If you’ve maintained proper holdbacks and the lien is from a subcontractor or supplier you never contracted with directly, you may have a strong defence against personal liability beyond the holdback amount.
- Consider your options for responding to the lien. Under section 44, you can pay the claimed amount into court, which removes the lien from your property while the dispute is resolved. You can post security (such as a letter of credit) under Section 45 to have the lien vacated while defending the claim on its merits. Or you can defend the lien claim through litigation, challenging its validity or amount.
- Understand the impact on your property. While a lien is registered, you typically cannot sell or refinance your property without addressing the lien. If you’re in the middle of a property transaction, a newly registered lien can derail the deal. In time-sensitive situations, posting security to vacate the lien may be the fastest path to completing your transaction.
Timing for Liens
The Ontario Construction Act operates on strict, unforgiving timelines that both lien claimants and defendants must understand. These deadlines can make or break construction lien claims and defences.
The 60-day registration deadline under Section 31(2) is the first critical timeline. In most cases, a lien claimant is required to file his/her claim within a period of 60 days following the last supply of services or materials to the project. In the case of contractors, this normally takes 60 days following a substantial completion of the contract or subcontract. Failure to meet this deadline results in the extinction of any lien rights; the exceptions to this are very few.
The concept of “substantial completion” plays a pivotal role in determining when these timelines begin. Section 2 defines substantial completion as when the improvement is ready for use or is being used for the purposes intended, and when it is capable of completion or correction at a cost of not more than 3% of the first $250,000 of the contract price and 2% of the balance.
Under section 36, the 45-day preservation deadline. Once a lien is registered, the claimant should then ensure that it is “preserved” by initiating a court action and registering a certificate of action within 45 days. Lapse of time to maintain a lien before this deadline leads to an automatic expiry of the lien.
The 90-day vacate, or perfect deadline under section 37, applies to lien claimants who have preserved their liens. The claimant has to put the matter to trial within 90 days after preservation. Such a deadline makes lien claimants diligently pursue their claims, as opposed to having liens stacked on property forever.
The holdback release timeline under section 23 is equally important. The Act places the onus on property proprietors to save a 10 percent holdback within the stipulated post-substantial completion. This holdback safeguards the owners against subcontractor and supplier claims. Knowing this timeline enables the owners to manage their need to withhold with the wish of their contractors to receive all their payments.
Best Practices for Construction Liens
Whether you’re a property owner, contractor, or other party involved in construction projects, following best practices can prevent lien claims from arising or strengthen your position if disputes occur.
- Draft comprehensive written contracts before work begins. A clear, detailed contract is your first line of defence against payment disputes. Specify the scope, payment, change order processes, remedies of deficiencies and dispute resolution methods.
- Maintain meticulous payment records. Document every payment made, every invoice received, and every communication about payment. Obtain statutory declarations from contractors under section 32 confirming they’ve paid their subcontractors and suppliers before releasing payment.
- Implement proper holdback procedures under Section 22 of the Construction Lien Act. Calculate the required 10% holdback on each payment, maintain it properly, and don’t release it until the statutory holdback period has expired and you’ve confirmed no liens have been registered.
- Obtain lien waivers from contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers as work progresses and payments are made. A lien waiver is a document where a party acknowledges receipt of payment and waives their right to claim a lien for that work.
- Respond immediately to lien notices. The timelines under the Ontario Construction Act are unforgiving. When you receive notice of a lien or discover one registered against your property, contact legal counsel immediately.
Pacific Legal’s Approach to Construction Lien Disputes and Litigation
At Pacific Legal, we are aware that construction lien issues are not just the legal side of things, but also your property, your business connections, and your pocketbook. Our approach combines thorough knowledge of the Construction Lien Act with practical, business-focused strategies designed to protect your interests efficiently.
We begin every construction lien matter with a comprehensive assessment of your position. Our team will go through all the documentation, evaluate the legal force of the claim to the lien in accordance with the applicable provisions of the Construction Act, find the possible defences, and assess the compliance with the procedures in accordance with the requirements of the Act. We look beyond the face of the lien to understand the underlying dispute and determine whether settlement, negotiation, or aggressive litigation is the best path forward.
Our lawyers understand the time-sensitive nature of construction liens in Ontario. We act rapidly to new claims of lien so that you do not miss any important deadlines under Sections 31, 36, and 37 that are likely to undermine your defences.
We also emphasize preventive strategies. For clients undertaking construction projects, we provide contract review, holdback management advice under Section 22, and risk assessment to minimize the likelihood of facing lien claims. In the case of contractor clients, we make sure that they are familiar with their rights and liabilities in liability matters, which allows them to maintain claims in case of legitimate payment disputes.
Our litigation approach is strategic and cost-conscious. We understand that the goal isn’t just to win in court, it’s to achieve the best overall outcome for your situation. The most recent cases reveal the multi-faceted nature of the construction lien priorities, as well as the need to employ experienced attorneys to negotiate through the case under the Ontario Construction Act.
Why Choose Pacific Legal for Construction Liens
Pacific Legal brings specialized expertise in construction lien defence to property owners, contractors, and other parties facing lien claims in Ontario. Our track record of successfully defending clients against unjustified liens, negotiating favourable settlements, and navigating the complexities of the Construction Act makes us a trusted partner for construction dispute resolution. We combine responsive service, practical business judgment, and thorough legal knowledge to protect your property and financial interests when construction payment disputes arise.



